Supporting Constitutional and Evidence-Based Public Conviction Registry Laws
National

NC: 10TH CIRCUIT RULES SPECIAL CONDITIONS ALLOWING PROBATION COMPLETE DISCRETION OVER INTERNET USE IS EXCESSIVE

From Florida Action Committee:

The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in US v. Blair, ruled that a special condition on the Defendant’s Internet use that was “limited to those the defendant requests to use, and which the probation officer authorizes” involved a greater deprivation of liberty than is reasonably necessary for deterring criminal activity because it allows the probation office to completely ban the defendant’s use of the Internet by failing to place any restraints on a probation officer’s ability to restrict a defendant’s Internet access.

Blair argued that this special condition was more restrictive “than is reasonably necessary” in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 3583(d)(2). The Court agreed.

While THE COURT STILL CAN BAN INTERNET USE, a special condition of release that gives the probation office discretion to ban completely a defendant’s use doesn’t fly because it allows the probation office the discretion to completely ban a means of communication that has become a necessary component of modern life, which is a greater deprivation than necessary.

Read more on the Florida Action Committee website

Leave a Reply

back to top